phenomimes and psychomimes: Difference between revisions

From Lojban
Jump to navigation Jump to search
No edit summary
No edit summary
Line 6: Line 6:
In Lojban, the expressions parallel to them are accomplished with the [[Experimental cmavo]] [[tai'i|tai'i]] and [[ci'oi|ci'oi]].
In Lojban, the expressions parallel to them are accomplished with the [[Experimental cmavo]] [[tai'i|tai'i]] and [[ci'oi|ci'oi]].
=== [https://groups.google.com/group/lojban/browse_thread/thread/ff627876d9a9c792 Discussions] ===
=== [https://groups.google.com/group/lojban/browse_thread/thread/ff627876d9a9c792 Discussions] ===
* Could you attempt to explain that in a way that means something to people who don't speak any of those languages, and don't already know what you're talking about? "It's just like this feature you're never heard of in a language you don't know" is less than useful. -- Mon, 29 Oct 2012 10:30:41 -0500, Adam Lopresto
*[[xalbo]]:
*:Could you attempt to explain that in a way that means something to people who don't speak any of those languages, and don't already know what you're talking about? "It's just like this feature you're never heard of in a language you don't know" is less than useful.
** Phenomimes and psychomimes are used in similar ways to onomatopoeia. In contrast to onomatopoeia, they give respectively uttered expressions to phenomena and mental states that do NOT necessarily make a sound. Similarly to onomatopoeia, speakers of a language share meanings of certain phenomimes and psychomimes, while sometimes they invent one's peculiar phenomimes and psychomimes.  
** Phenomimes and psychomimes are used in similar ways to onomatopoeia. In contrast to onomatopoeia, they give respectively uttered expressions to phenomena and mental states that do NOT necessarily make a sound. Similarly to onomatopoeia, speakers of a language share meanings of certain phenomimes and psychomimes, while sometimes they invent one's peculiar phenomimes and psychomimes.  
** How do I invent a phenomime or a psychomime? Just like giving a piece of background music to a scene of a drama, call to mind a piece of sound suitable to a phenomenon or a mental state; convert it to a string of phonemes; in Lojban, utter it just after {tai'i} or {ci'oi}; that's it.  
** How do I invent a phenomime or a psychomime? Just like giving a piece of background music to a scene of a drama, call to mind a piece of sound suitable to a phenomenon or a mental state; convert it to a string of phonemes; in Lojban, utter it just after '''tai'i''' or '''ci'oi'''; that's it.  
** It may happen that a distinction between a phenomime, a psychomime and an onomatopoeia is vague. In this case, use {tai'i}: it is defined as a broader term than '''ci'oi''' and '''sa'ei'''. -- Wed, 31 Oct 2012 11:03:48 +0900, guskant
**[[guskant]]:
* Problem is, there are no neutral or Lojban-only onomatopoeia for things. -- Tue, 30 Oct 2012 11:08:00 -0700 (PDT), la .lindar.
**:It may happen that a distinction between a phenomime, a psychomime and an onomatopoeia is vague. In this case, use {tai'i}: it is defined as a broader term than '''ci'oi''' and '''sa'ei'''.
** That's right. However, it sometimes happens that even Japanese listeners don't understand the meanings of phemomimes, psychomimes and onomatopoeia used by a Japanese speaker. These words do not independently convey precise meanings to the listeners. If a speaker wants to reduce vagueness of the meanings of them, it is indispensable to accompany them with content words. -- Wed, 31 Oct 2012 11:03:48 +0900, guskant
*[[la .lindar.]]:
*:Problem is, there are no neutral or Lojban-only onomatopoeia for things.
**[[guskant]]:
**:That's right. However, it sometimes happens that even Japanese listeners don't understand the meanings of phemomimes, psychomimes and onomatopoeia used by a Japanese speaker. These words do not independently convey precise meanings to the listeners. If a speaker wants to reduce vagueness of the meanings of them, it is indispensable to accompany them with content words.

Revision as of 13:09, 21 May 2014

Nepali, Korean and Japanese languages have many phenomimes and psychomimes.

In Lojban, the expressions parallel to them are accomplished with the Experimental cmavo tai'i and ci'oi.

Discussions

  • xalbo:
    Could you attempt to explain that in a way that means something to people who don't speak any of those languages, and don't already know what you're talking about? "It's just like this feature you're never heard of in a language you don't know" is less than useful.
    • Phenomimes and psychomimes are used in similar ways to onomatopoeia. In contrast to onomatopoeia, they give respectively uttered expressions to phenomena and mental states that do NOT necessarily make a sound. Similarly to onomatopoeia, speakers of a language share meanings of certain phenomimes and psychomimes, while sometimes they invent one's peculiar phenomimes and psychomimes.
    • How do I invent a phenomime or a psychomime? Just like giving a piece of background music to a scene of a drama, call to mind a piece of sound suitable to a phenomenon or a mental state; convert it to a string of phonemes; in Lojban, utter it just after tai'i or ci'oi; that's it.
    • guskant:
      It may happen that a distinction between a phenomime, a psychomime and an onomatopoeia is vague. In this case, use {tai'i}: it is defined as a broader term than ci'oi and sa'ei.
  • la .lindar.:
    Problem is, there are no neutral or Lojban-only onomatopoeia for things.
    • guskant:
      That's right. However, it sometimes happens that even Japanese listeners don't understand the meanings of phemomimes, psychomimes and onomatopoeia used by a Japanese speaker. These words do not independently convey precise meanings to the listeners. If a speaker wants to reduce vagueness of the meanings of them, it is indispensable to accompany them with content words.