joi: Difference between revisions
Jump to navigation
Jump to search
(citing my sources!) |
No edit summary |
||
Line 3: | Line 3: | ||
*[[BPFK_Section:_Non-logical_Connectives#Formal_definitions]] | *[[BPFK_Section:_Non-logical_Connectives#Formal_definitions]] | ||
** '''X''' joi '''Y''' = lo gunma be '''X''' .e '''Y''' | ** '''X''' joi '''Y''' = lo gunma be '''X''' .e '''Y''' | ||
=guskant's writing= | |||
*[[gadri:_an_unofficial_commentary_from_a_logical_point_of_view#Relation_between_jo.27u.2C_joi.2C_ce_and_gadri]] | |||
** '''X''' joi '''Y''' = lo gunma be '''X''' .e '''Y''' .e no drata be '''X''' .e '''Y''' | |||
** {joi} forms a "non-distributive plural constant". | |||
=[https://lojban.github.io/cll/14/14/ CLL 14.14 Non-logical connectives]= | =[https://lojban.github.io/cll/14/14/ CLL 14.14 Non-logical connectives]= |
Revision as of 14:52, 28 October 2018
BPFK Sections
- BPFK_Section:_Non-logical_Connectives#cmavo:_joi_.28JOI.29
- BPFK_Section:_Non-logical_Connectives#Formal_definitions
- X joi Y = lo gunma be X .e Y
guskant's writing
- gadri:_an_unofficial_commentary_from_a_logical_point_of_view#Relation_between_jo.27u.2C_joi.2C_ce_and_gadri
- X joi Y = lo gunma be X .e Y .e no drata be X .e Y
- {joi} forms a "non-distributive plural constant".
CLL 14.14 Non-logical connectives
(Link added for reference — but all the usual disclaimers apply: CLL says quite contradictory things about joi and jo'u.)
gimste definition
non-logical connective: mixed conjunction; 'and' meaning 'mixed together', forming a mass.
la lalxu's diagram
xorxes's Lojban jbovlaste definition
nalylogji jonma'o .i te jorne le li'erla'i le se li'erla'i ja'e lo gunma
Non-logical connective. Joins the preceding argument and the following argument, with-result: a gunma.
This is compatible with the BPFK definition above (whew!) when taking the resulting gunma to satisfy gunma le li'erla'i .e le se li'erla'i.
broda joi brodu
That definition is fine for SUMTI joi SUMTI, but what about tanru units? The resulting broda joi brodu can't be a gunma (mass).
la ŭakci suggests the following semantics [source: #ckule on Oct 28, 2018]:
«da broda joi brodu» → 1) da broda i je da brodu; 2) su’o di zo’u da ckaji di i je lo ka broda kei je lo ka brodu cu pagbu di; 2a) lo ka broda kei je lo ka brodu cu simsa di; 2b) lo ka broda je brodu na du di.